Blog powered by Typepad

« 'We need to talk about America'! | Main | He wasn't all bad, that Harvey Weinstein! »

Wednesday, 10 January 2018

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

If the Japanese had been allies in more than name, the Germans in general, and Rommel in particular, would have profited from the lessons that the Jap military learned the hard way with regard to defence against seaborne invasion. Initially, in places such as Tarawa, they took the approach that Rommel favoured, which was to fight the Americans at the beaches and prevent them from landing altogether. That didn't work out too well, and when the Americans hit Okinawa, they had come up with plan b, which was to let them land, and stop them at the main line(s) of resistance, which had been set up inland. This of course tallied with what von Rundstedt was thinking.

Unfortunately for the Americans, the Japs were absolute masters at defensive fighting. Their bunkers were brilliantly sighted with interlocking fields of fire, they were linked by networks of tunnels, which meant that they kept reappearing in positions the Americans thought they had cleared, and their camouflage and fire discipline were world class.

Much as I admire Rommel, I have to go with von R. All I can say is thank God the Jerries didn't pay too much attention to what the Japs were doing on the other side of the World.!!!

Thanks for that, Richard. I must confess to my ignorance when it comes to Japanese military strategic and tactical thinking although it became very clear that they were masters of defence. Again, through gritted teeth, I thank God for the A-bomb which saved countless American lives by obviating the need for an invasion of the Japanese mainland.

saved countless American lives

And also British and Empire/Commonwealth lives. Remember there was a campaign in Burma which was intended to push on into Siam [Thailand] who were co-belligerants of the Japanese and then on into Malaya to Singapore. Refer to Sir William Slim's book Defeat into Victory which is the story of the "Forgottten Fourteenth Army". Likewise Borneo where the Australians were the principal military force.

Without the Atomic bomb who knows how many allied military and civilian lives would have been lost.

Just after the end of WW2 and into the 1950s I heard my Dad and his fellow vets who served in the Pacific, refer to the "Yellow Menace" that had fallen under Communism. This I took to be a blanket term for Orientals as we called them way back when and included Japanese people. While the A-Bomb took care of Japan and rightly so, many WW2 vets we knew suggested the Bomb was the ultimate answer to the "Yellow Menace". I had an uncle who served in the Far East as it was known then, usually meaning China/Burma. He didn't return home until 1947. His solution to the Yellow Menace was pretty much the same.

AD's comment prompts me to acknowledge with no small gratitude as I have alluded to in some earlier comment as, without the equal contributions from the Coastwatchers - Guadalcanal would have been nigh on impossible.

(Apologies for the convoluted syntax - but it's early dammit!)

Its exceedingly (at this hour) difficult to find a proper link:

"Most of this intelligence came from Australian Coastwatchers. These were intelligence operatives based on the scattered Pacific islands, whose role was to keep an eye out for Japanese activity. Based in places such as Bougainville and New Georgia, they radioed in reports of incoming Japanese planes. This allowed the Cactus flyers to get into the air before the Japanese arrived."

https://www.warhistoryonline.com/world-war-ii/cactus-air-force-guadalcanal-mm.html

https://audioboom.com/posts/6212540-the-conquering-tide-war-in-the-pacific-islands-1942-1944-war-in-the-pacific-islands-1942-1944-by-ian-w-toll-part-1-of-6

Too, without bearing in mind Australia's role directing the USN it is equally difficult to appreciate the gravity of Richard's comment.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_the_Coral_Sea

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Your Information

(Name is required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)