Blog powered by Typepad

« An absolute 'MUST READ' by A E-P | Main | Start your day here with a headache! »

Thursday, 26 March 2015

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Hi David

I too have been reading a book, Liberal Fascism by J. Goldberg; and he has a long section about Wilson's performance in the first WW. In this he names him as the first of the liberal fascists, his creation of an essentially natioanlist socialised war economy with the deliberate intention of using the war as a launch pad for national renewal presaged Lenin, Mussolini, Hitler and later Che Guavara and all the rest (Goldberg's words not mine).

To the extent it is true it quite changes everything I thought I knew about the US entry into the war and as a result the motivations for Wilson's performance at Versailles.

Anyway keep up the good work Duffy old boy, I absolutely love your blog.

(that's enough adulation, back to work)

"I absolutely love your blog" - ah, 'Cuffers', you say that to all the girls!

As to your main point, I should make clear that admiration for the trio (quartet, really, but the Italian doesn't count) is limited to their huge efforts to try and sort out some order from total chaos. All three of them were, of course, products of their different backgrounds. They did so with the usual mixture of idealism and self-interest in which the former outweighed the latter only when no self interest was involved! But even so, I doubt if any three other politicians would have done better, not least because so many of the problems were intractable. Innumerable books have been written by 'wiseacres' after the event criticising their efforts but whatever settlement had been reached, Herr Hitler would have swept it aside with contempt.

Or put it this way, how do you think Obama, Cameron and Hollande would have managed? Quelle horreure!

"how do you think Obama, Cameron and Hollande would have managed?" Is that the beginning of a really bad joke, dear duffers?

Noticed David, something might be of interest;

http://warontherocks.com/2015/03/warchives-rescuing-tommy/

Ah, you guessed, Miss Red, you see, there was this American - sort of, Englishman and Frenchman and they had to sort out the problems of the world . . . yeeeeees, quite!

Thanks, JK, and as it happens the sacrifices of the Indian army on the Western Front has never received the publicity it deserves.

The comments to this entry are closed.