Blog powered by Typepad

« 'Mutti' reaps her rotten harvest | Main | Why I keep 'schtum' about Trump »

Tuesday, 17 October 2017


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

I am listening to him now, he has done the audio version of "A Game of Thrones" in which he plays something like 72 different parts. He was excellent.

This "Game of Thrones" seems to have taken over the world - 'SoD' never stops droning on about it! - except for here, deep in the wild hinterland of 'Zummerzet'! So why do I just know, deep down inside myself, that it is probably a load of old codswallop?

What a man! I sure hope there are more where he came from.

Well, GoT before the television program took over, was indeed excellent. A myriad of interesting characters that the author was never afraid to kill off, with an enthralling story line, the attraction of "Houses" and their banners (a source of endless entertainment) plus magic and dragons. A mystery to be solved; a depiction of barbaric slaughter; companion Dire wolves - a bit for everyone.

And then they started filming it. Which was still good, they pulled in a number of excellent actors (even if we knew that Ned Stark would suffer a fate when they cast Sean Bean). It stuck close to the books, did us a favour by trimming some characters we were never going to remember anyway and kept looking towards G R R Martin's finale. However, he didn't keep up, and the writers have now taken over, and revealed exactly why they write stories for television rather than books. It's still good, but it's a whole new flavour from Martin's writing and is also suffering from "Let's make this one series two series...serieses....seriesi?" and "Let's give this highly successful series some money but not quite enough for their needs" (leading to nonsensical plot changes such as the disappearance of the one remaining Dire wolf). It is good. It is a good series, but I don't think it would have risen above the common herd with the production team it has now if G R R Martin hadn't written so much of it to start with. And now we're going to have some break off series, and it'll end up like "ST:Discovery". They may even throw in a Bechdel test, just for good measure. I am happy that this series will be the last, and I wish G R R Martin a speedy voyage towards his last book(s) which I suspect will be written by his son, or close friend and will never be as good as the original stuff.

I suppose "a free scholarship" is preferable to one that you have to pay for.


The comments to this entry are closed.