Blog powered by Typepad

« The Sunday Rumble: 10.1.21 | Main | Brexit Bacon Butty border ban shock! »

Monday, 11 January 2021

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

SoD,

The superiority of the EU laid bare:

https://www.timworstall.com/2021/01/death-by-solidarity/

Wiggers

Well Sir,
I've been waiting patiently,
for your Report on the 'Lincoln' book
you teased US with, during your last
lament about your tardy reading habit.
Respecty,
Bill
Ford Theater Actors Assoc.

Bill, I am admonished and I deserve it! I began the Lincoln book and was looking forward to getting into the heart of it but, alas, was diverted by something else. The story of my reading life, I regret to say! Now, of course, I can't find the bloody thing! Life's a bitch and then it rains!

James Holland has an interesting revisionist patter around the "middle bit" between strategy and tactics, what he calls the operational, that was the Jerries undoing.

All that over engineered unreliable kit and the burden it placed on logistics to maintain it, meant the Jerries were only meant for knock-out blows, not attritional long-running fronts. Inferior but mass manufactured kit would grind them down if victory wasn't achieved PDFQ.

And so the better allied operational performance in the middle of the sandwich overwhelmed the tactical superiority of the Jerries below - those cheap as chips, robust, reliable Shermans, T-34's and Bren guns outperformed the Tigers, Panthers and MG-42's at the operational level and squished the Jerries' tactical advantages. And that in turn embarrassed their strategy by turning planned knockout blows into operational slugfests.

The operational level has been much ignored in the WWII book world, fork lift trucks being not as sexy as Tiger tanks. James Holland redresses that balance in his writings.

Just finished his book on operation Husky, invasion of Sicily. Really good illustration of his point: the allied logistics were awesome.

SoD

Wiggers, the 27 states call out the EU when it messes up, and the EU calls out the 27 states when they mess up. The confederation's two way conflict keeps all power players more exposed and honest, and the people therefore more informed and protected.

Blighty however is a different kettle of fish. The centralised model has failed by removing that two-way check and balance.

A federal Blighty with the old heptarchy, the seven states of England, plus Scotland, NI, Wales, Cornwall, and London (all the substrates that have historical precedent), now that would work well.

But as you know, it ain't gonna happen.
Which means we were better off getting our confederal oversight externally from Brussels since it was never on the radar internally within Blighty.

SoD

"I hate to admit it, but my Eurosceptic father was right about Brexit
I called for a second referendum. But the new deal has turned me into a Brexiteer."

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2021/01/12/hate-admit-eurosceptic-father-right-brexit/

Wish I had a brainy son like that!

Hehehe, bull's eye Gaffer!

SoD

“ the 27 states call out the EU when it messes up” and it ignores them.

Like when the whole EU executive resigned in 1999 due to pressure from the states?

When was the last time anyone in the executive resigned in Blighty? Even after massacring 91,000 Brits they're still in there.

The EU confederation works well as a two-way feedback loop, keeping power under control at both ends: member states and Confederate centre. That simply doesn't occur in Blighty's lop-sided, centralisation only, system.

SoD

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Your Information

(Name is required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)